Outsourcing Pricing - Cost Plus vs. Unit Pricing vs. Fixed Fee. Performance Bonuses and Penalties.
Much time is spent by outsourcing clients and suppliers determining the optimal pricing structure for an outsourcing deal. Suppliers want to make a reasonable profit, and clients want to ensure they are getting value for what they spend. Some pricing structures are simple. If an easily counted and comparable “unit†exists for pricing – such as “cost per call†on a call center deal - then the pricing structure is fairly straightforward and easily determined - so long is the price is “reasonableâ€.
Unfortunately, simplicity is more often the exception than the rule. Finding clearly definable and manageable units that can be priced on a fee-for-service or a fixed-fee basis isn’t always possible, or becomes so complicated; counting becomes almost as big an effort as the services being provided. Even with the “simple†call center example, one must define what represents a “callâ€. Do you count the number of inbound calls to the ACD, or the number of tickets entered by the agent? Are there exclusions? – say for a system outage, where many people are calling in for the same issue?
Another seemingly simple arrangement is a cost-per-hour. Programming hours are a good example. The supplier provides a somewhat “fixed†number of staff (with varying skill sets) to a project. The personnel account for and document their time spent on the project. The hours spent times the headcount easily generates an invoice. But how does the client actually audit the time spent by a technician developing a new system?
Many deals that have no clear unit mechanism for compensating the outsourcing provider will turn to cost plus. Add up all the costs that the outsourcer is responsible for (salaries, supplies, travel, etc.), apply a pre-agreed formula for overhead, then add a contractually-determined profit margin, and this becomes the price for services. Most of the large mega-deals end up with this arrangement. Oh, the deal will “outline†a future "unit pricing" strategy - based on gathering tons of data, and implementing new, yet undiscovered measuring systems - but there are usually enough conditions in the contract to give both sides and easy out, and the contract ends up cost plus for the duration.
Each pricing formula has its strengths and weaknesses. Fixed-price and unit-price deals are sometimes difficult for the client to verify, but provide greater incentives for the supplier to generate efficiencies. Cost plus deals are relatively easy to verify, but lack incentives for the supplier to do anything other than maintain the status quo. So what’s the answer? Well, it would seem that the optimal pricing mechanism will accomplish the following:
- Compensates the supplier fairly, where compensation is not only based on the level of production, but its quality;
- Has built-in efficiency incentives, where the client will benefit from these efficiencies with lower costs;
- Clear, verifiable and auditable invoicing amounts.
None of the standard basic pricing mechanisms has clear-cut incentives for either quality or efficiency. Asking an outsourcing supplier to operate at a loss for “x†number of years until they gain promised efficiencies isn’t a likely outcome of contract negotiations (unless the client is a really crafty negotiator). Asking a client to pay a service premium well into the future for promised improvements in quality or efficiency over time, usually doesn’t work either.
Variable unit pricing seems to be something everyone likes. For the outsourcing provider, technology deflators ensure that processors and storage will get faster, smaller and cheaper over time, and that the use of the technology will always grow - hence they make more money (at least in theory). For the outsourcing client, the fees they pay via the unit price are directly tied to the amount of technology they use.
The selected pricing mechanism must balance all factors, and be something that both sides trust and can rely on. A mechanism that will allow the provider to make a reasonable profit, and one that will allow the client to feel they are getting reasonable value for their expenditure. Typically, this balance is created in the form of contract incentives for outstanding performance, or penalties for sub-par performance. These "incentives" or "penalties" can be easily implemented regardless of the underlying contractual compensation mechanism. But negotiating them can be a problem. No outsourcing firm wants to pay a penalty unless they've really messed up. Customers don't want to pay a bonus if the performance isn't viewed as exceptional.
It may be the terms we use - "penalty" and "bonus" that cause many of the problems. Many outsourcing firms won't even allow the term "penalty" to be used in the contract, since it may imply contractual default. Some outsourcing attorneys even say that courts view a penalty as a meaningless term. A bonus implies outstanding performance. The objective statistics may show that performance is exceptional, but in many cases, the subjective view of the client doesn't match these so-called "objective" statistics.
I've even heard of subjective performance measures being attempted - where the client and outsourcer periodically agree on the outsourcer's performance and pay (or deduct) bonus or penalties accordingly.
I'm afraid I don't have any perfects answers on how to effectively structure bonus and penalties, but I would like to hear your views. If you have any interesting, innovative pricing and/or performance-related compensation techniques (and whether they worked or didn't work), please comment.
B. Erenberger OMS
In the early 20th century,
In the early 20th century, the number of office workers began increasing. Many such men and women were required to wear neckties, because it was perceived as improving work attitudes, morale, and sales. Thanks for sharing the information.
Regards,
Jack-Bow Ties
The Windows Phone 7 software
The Windows Phone 7 software debuted on Feb. 15 at the Mobile World assembly 2010 in Barcelona, Spain. 5.11 tactical series
The personnel account for
The personnel account for and document their time spent on the project. The hours spent times the headcount easily generates an invoice. Thanks for sharing.
Regards,
seo reseller programs
Cost plus deals are
Cost plus deals are relatively easy to verify, but lack incentives for the supplier to do anything other than maintain the status quo. Thanks for sharing.
Regards,
Locations for Business france
Good post.
Just read your post and would like to thank you for maintaining such a cool blog.
commercial property info
I've looked into this many
I've looked into this many times and keep running the two sets of numbers that matter. tactical gear
If you don't have this
If you don't have this mechanism in place its pointless afterall you don't want your outsourcers to need debt solutions because you are nailing them to the ground. You want to all know how to make money online and that means a fair deal for all. I use outsourcers all the time in my grooms speech and piano tutorial businesses and I make sure they always get a fair deal.
I believe that every pricing
I believe that every pricing formula has its pros and cons. Working for fixed-price or unit-price can be somewhat difficult to prove but the supplier is more likely to do a better job. While the cost plus deals are more easier to check but leave the supplier with nothing extra and thus you'll get what you pay for. Tom, Job search site
Dog life jackets make it
Dog life jackets make it easy to get an overboard dog back to safety by placing a sturdy handle on your canine’s back. They also act as floatation devices to keep less capable swimmers above water. Many prudent dog lovers have chosen to outfit their pooch with a life jacket before hitting the ocean, lake, or river.For more about dog life jacket online please visit this site.....
DOG LIFE JACKET
For my business outsourcing
For my business outsourcing is crucial. In my how to fight and online spanish classes business all content was created with outsourcing. I don't do any on my but my design on puppy toilet training was done this way. cute pick up lines is only for fun so outsourcing was not needed.
A leading restaurant of the
A leading restaurant of the Napoleonic era was the Véry, which was lavishly decorated and boasted a menu with extensive choices of soups.
Regards,
Marketing Communications Software
Any way I'll be subscribing
Any way I'll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon.low cost car insurance company
If you have outsourcing
If you have outsourcing contracts you are responsible for managing, review our management processes and services.
Regards,
Buy Safety Signs
Even if you are not
Even if you are not interested in our services, this information may give you some ideas on how to improve your outsourced vendor.
Herbal medicine course
The types of property and
The types of property and communications necessary for your business sector will already be in place.
Invest in Europe
I wanted to thank you for
I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post
kids toys
This blog is for exchanges
This blog is for exchanges regarding outsourcing management and governance issues. and i would like to be a member of this blog thanks for sharing the info.
Regards,
Salon Software
Thank you for another great
Thank you for another great article. I have a presentation next week, and I am on the look for such information. Thanks a lot.
Regards,
Inward investment
idea
A mechanism that will allow the provider to make a reasonable profit, and one that will allow the client to feel they are getting reasonable value for their expenditure.
--------------------
AffiloJetpack | AffiloJetpack Review | AffiloJetpack Bonus
When you outsource it is
When you outsource it is important to look at the quality and also the expenditure.
Custom Remodelers
Australian mortgage brokers
information about the topic is great. how do u get this. i love to read about such knowledge that people share. please keep it up.
Australian mortgage brokers
There may be strategic plans
There may be strategic plans that the client does not wish to share with the supplier.
Regards,
seo reseller
This forum is for
This forum is for pharmaceutical specialists in the CRO world. It was great being a part here.
office supplies online
FOREX BROKERS
thats amazing mate.i love every word of it.its a pleasure to read this article thanks.
FOREX BROKERS
It can save a lot of money
It can save a lot of money for companies.
claremont auto glass
It Looks like a very nice
It Looks like a very nice and interesting idea, but the problem is, it will cost a lot to the homeowner to take services of a professional interior decorator thanks for post.
Regards,
Jack - how to save your marriage
A mechanism that will allow
A mechanism that will allow the provider to make a reasonable profit, and one that will allow the client to feel they are getting reasonable value for their expenditure. Thanks for sharing.
Regards
investment in ashford
A mechanism that will allow
A mechanism that will allow the provider to make a reasonable profit, and one that will allow the client to feel they are getting reasonable value for their expenditure. Thanks for sharing.
Regards
cheap auto insurance
appreciated your
appreciated your professional way of writing this post. Thanks, you have made it very easy for me to understand.
Regards,
yamaha bags
This post was very nicely
This post was very nicely written, and it also contains a lot of useful facts.
Regards,
Moving Houston
This blog is for exchanges
This blog is for exchanges regarding outsourcing management and governance issues. and i would like to be a member of this blog thanks for sharing the info.
Regards,
Jack - investment in london
The business deals are done
The business deals are done according to the work we do. The information about the outsourcing is great here.
Regards,
invest in Warwickshire
The client satisfaction is
The client satisfaction is with the money he is going to spend. This is good enough if he agrees to the reasonable quote.
Regards,
web design minnesota
The pricing depends on these
The pricing depends on these constraints is good to know but there should be a bench mark for the limitation we need to fix.
Regards,
mobile casino
But some environments: macro
But some environments: macro and micro. The macro environment includes the and price may be negotiated after performance begins, but the contractor may and the guaranteed maximum, incentive types of contracts... invest in staffs
Globe-to-Loc
Good article. Outsourcing pricing models are quite complex at times, because quite a few times, local labor-pool dynamics and variations kick into play. Albeit, successful companies must do a survey in a particular supplier destination in order to determine safe perimeters of payment. I've written an article on overall business change in a globalizing world that makes sense to this blog (http://www.articlesbase.com/strategic-planning-articles/winds-of-busines...)
Some outsourcing attorneys
Some outsourcing attorneys even say that courts view a penalty as a meaningless term. A bonus implies outstanding performance. Thanks for sharing.
Regards,
michigan auto insurance
A mechanism will allow the
A mechanism will allow the provider to make a reasonable profit, and one that will allow the client to feel they are getting reasonable value for their expenditure. Thanks for sharing.
Regards,
michigan auto insurance
Yeah your correct great
Yeah your correct great article and nice sharing with us... Rainwater Harvesting Systems
It was nice and great work
It was nice and great work done by you. Thanks for sharing. Nice article. Thanks for the post.
Regards,
math tutor brooklyn
Hi, I see your blog. It is
Hi, I see your blog. It is very good I hope you will see my blog. You show some very valuable information. So, nice! Thanks for sharing.
Regards,
chicago movers
I found this informative and
I found this informative and interesting blog so i think so its very useful and knowledge able. I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well. Thanks for sharing.
Regards,
property warning signs
Fixed-price and unit-price
Fixed-price and unit-price deals are sometimes difficult for the client to verify, but provide greater incentives for the supplier to generate efficiencies. Thanks for the information in this article.
Regards,
Custom Remodelers Minnesota
Many outsourcing firms won't
Many outsourcing firms won't even allow the term penalty to be used in the contract, since it may imply contractual default. Thanks for sharing.
Regards,
moving company minneapolis
nice
Some outsourcing attorneys even say that courts view a penalty as a meaningless term. A bonus implies outstanding performance. The objective statistics may show that performance is exceptional, but in many cases, the subjective view of the client doesn't match these so-called "objective" statistics.
Portable Display Booths
Cost plus deals are
Cost plus deals are relatively easy to verify, but lack incentives for the supplier to do anything other than maintain the status quo. Thanks for sharing.
Regards,
massage therapist california
Well for outstanding
Well for outstanding performance, or penalties for sub-par performance. These "incentives" or "penalties" can be easily implemented regardless of the underlying contractual compensation mechanism. But negotiating them can be a problem. No outsourcing firm wants to pay a penalty unless they've really messed. hip hop rings
Simplicity is more often the
Simplicity is more often the exception than the rule. Finding clearly definable and manageable units that can be priced on a fee-for-service or a fixed-fee basis is always possible, or becomes so complicated. Thanks for sharing.
Regards,
Company locations
The pricing structure is a
The pricing structure is a significant fact for business, but also will like to mention the customer benefit of quality coding and achieving the expected results is an important part of a very well written contract. Thanks for sharing.
Regards,
investment in kent
auto insurance
auto insurance